Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Reggie VanderVeen's avatar

That's what I love about your stuff, Brian. Your doubt of any viable "gold standard" in existence out there in the world of "science" is...well, gold. You even knock your own work occasionally which gives you credibility. Keep up the good work pointing out the bad...even when you are inclined to criticize your own efforts (or at least adjust your positions from time to time). Kudos.

Expand full comment
Shy Boy's avatar

I'm going to break my usual discipline and post a comment that just says

Rah-rah! Go Brian! Well said! Hear here! ^^THIS!^^ Excellent article, will share widely, would subscribe all over again!!

Okay... Ok. I maybe do have a couple of arguably more substantial things to throw into the mix. No claim that they cohere. Just reflections on different facets.

First, the attitude you take here is in no way a nihilistic or even cynical view of science. This is a mature and clear-eyed view of the pursuit of knowledge as it is actually practiced, embedded in society and shaped by institutional frameworks. I sometimes have trouble getting people to see that, especially if they've never worked in research. (Although, professional researchers are unfortunately often true believers themselves, or at least will reflexively toe the party line in mixed company. Some degree of survivorship bias, no doubt.)

Second, masks and criminality. Like the current kerfuffle in NYC about getting walk-in customers to momentarily drop their masks for the surveillance cameras. Like being told to put on your mask by the bank teller behind the window. Absurdities.

Third, a grab-bag of whatabouts... Japanese cultural norms around masking when contagious, as a "cover your cough" sort of thing, siezed upon and inverted. Non-RCT studies of mask use in surgical theaters not showing benefit. The protestations of air filtration professionals around the inadequacies of paper masks, with arguments based on fluid dynamics rather than RCTs. The spontaneous(?!) world-wide DIY t-shirt masking astroturf "movement". Ugh.

Expand full comment
107 more comments...

No posts